Australia’s pre-owned car market welcomed a new player on the ASX this week as Carma (ASX: CMA) made its much-anticipated debut. However, the digital car retailer experienced a rocky start, trading as low as $2.47 compared to its $2.70 issue price—an 8.5% drop on opening day.​

About Carma

Carma operates as a fully integrated digital platform for buying and selling pre-owned vehicles across Australia. Founded in 2021, its business model involves sourcing cars directly from consumers, auctions, and fleet operators, then reconditioning each vehicle at its Sydney hub. Every car undergoes a comprehensive 300-point inspection before being showcased online, where buyers can review detailed histories, arrange instant financing, and get vehicles delivered to their doorsteps.

Financial Highlights and Outlook

The company’s latest financials indicate ambitious projections. Carma is forecasting a 78% revenue surge for FY26—to $127.6 million—after only marginal growth of 3.6% in FY25. Despite these targets, the company anticipates continued annual losses near $35 million, as it seeks scale before reaching profitability. The average margin per vehicle currently sits around $4,000, with expectations for further expansion as Carma grows.​

IPO Details and Market Context

Carma’s IPO raised $100 million and was fully underwritten by Canaccord and E&P Capital, boosting credibility despite no equity options issued to managers. Proceeds will be channeled towards operating expenses, marketing, and the rollout of new “Sell-to Carma” centres—three of which are already functional in Sydney, with more launches coming soon. Notably, US-based Tiger Global holds a 25.8% post-IPO stake, reflecting substantial institutional support.​

Yet, the listing coincides with a turbulent phase in local equities, as the ASX Emerging Companies Index declined by 12.6% from recent highs. While comparisons are drawn with overseas peers like Carvana and Auto1—both of whom have achieved profit at scale—Carma’s journey to profitability remains in its early stages.

Risks and Growth Catalysts

Major risks revolve around ongoing losses and the possibility of further fundraising needs before profitability. On the upside, expansion into new states, further scaling, and enhanced per-vehicle margins present potential growth catalysts for the years ahead.​

Conclusion

Carma’s listing highlights the challenges facing tech-driven disruptors in a subdued market. With strong backers and ambitious plans, the company’s future moves—especially around margin improvement and interstate expansion—will be crucial for long-term investor sentiment.

Disclaimer: Ace Investors Pty Ltd (ABN 70 637 702 188), authorized representative of MF & CO. ASSET MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (AFSL No.520442). Ace Investors has made every effort to ensure the reliability and accuracy of the views and recommendations expressed in the reports published on its websites. Ace Investors' research is based on the information known to us or which was obtained from various sources, which we believe to be reliable and accurate to the best of our knowledge. Ace Investors provides only general financial information on its website, in reports, and through newsletters, without considering the financial needs or investment objectives of any individual user. We strongly advocate that you seek advice from your financial planner, advisor, or stockbroker on the merits of each recommendation before acting on any recommendation for your specific financial circumstances, and that you realize not all investments will be suitable for all subscribers. To the scope permitted by law, Ace Investors Pty Ltd excludes all liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of this website and any information published (including any indirect or consequential loss, any data loss or data corruption). If the law prohibits this exclusion, Ace Investors Pty Ltd hereby limits its liability to the scope permitted by law to resupply the services. The securities and financial products we study and share information on, in our reports, may have a product disclosure statement or other offer document associated with them. You should obtain copies of these before making any decision to acquire any security or product. You can refer to our Financial Services Guide.